Real Madrid: Fragile Victory Provides Breathing Room for Alonso

Amid a tumultuous atmosphere in Vitoria, Real Madrid secured a vital 2-1 victory against Alavés on Matchday 16 of La Liga, offering a temporary reprieve for coach Xabi Alonso. Following two consecutive home defeats—first to Celta Vigo and then to Manchester City—the pressure was mounting on the Merengues, who found themselves seven points adrift of FC Barcelona. In desperate need of a win to stave off crisis, Madrid faced further challenges with an unprecedented number of defensive absences, including Trent Alexander-Arnold, Éder Militão, Dani Carvajal, David Alaba, Ferland Mendy, and Fran García. With Carreras suspended, Alonso was forced to innovate defensively once again. Young Valdepeñas made his first start on the left flank, while Kylian Mbappé returned to the starting lineup after being rested against City.

Despite the victory, Alonso’s relief was tempered by concerns over the team’s performance. The win did little to dispel the lingering doubts surrounding the squad and its manager. Madrid’s display was far from convincing; they struggled to impose their game plan, which has previously defined Alonso’s coaching style. The hallmark traits of coordinated pressing and clean ball transitions appeared absent as Madrid adopted a survival mentality. Each match has become less about developing a cohesive strategy and more about preserving Alonso’s position—an approach that risks undermining his tactical identity.

The team’s reliance on individual brilliance rather than collective synergy was evident throughout the match. While some criticism has been directed at players for their performances, it is becoming increasingly difficult to absolve the coaching staff of responsibility. Alonso seems to have shifted from a proactive tactical project to crisis management, with immediate results taking precedence over long-term vision. The ongoing pressure raises an important question: Is this constant scrutiny beneficial for Real Madrid’s future? In the short term, it may yield results; however, it poses a significant threat to the club’s identity and coherence.

The Return of Madrid’s ‘Fantastic Four’

For the first time in 242 days, Kylian Mbappé, Vinícius Júnior, Jude Bellingham, and Rodrygo started together from the outset. On paper, this quartet promised excitement; however, the reality was a struggle for fluidity. Bellingham attempted to take on a playmaking role, contributing an assist but failing to exert enough influence to unlock Alavés’ defense fully. His performance highlighted ongoing challenges as he navigates his responsibilities within the team.

Mbappé showed flashes of brilliance with a stunning individual goal but appeared cautious overall—perhaps indicating lingering fitness concerns. Rodrygo emerged as Madrid’s standout performer; following his decisive goal against Manchester City, he consistently threatened Alavés’ backline and played a crucial role in securing victory for his side. Conversely, Vinícius Júnior endured a challenging evening but managed to provide a pivotal assist that ultimately saved both the match and Alonso’s position.

Looking Ahead

This hard-fought win against Alavés offers much-needed breathing room for Xabi Alonso and Real Madrid but does not erase the myriad questions surrounding their current state. With a decimated defense and an often disjointed style of play, Los Blancos are at a crossroads. The reintroduction of their star-studded attacking quartet raises hopes for revitalization yet underscores ongoing issues with cohesion and integration within the squad.

While this victory keeps Real Madrid within striking distance of FC Barcelona in La Liga standings, regaining their trademark identity and fluidity will be essential as they navigate an arduous path ahead. For now, Alonso breathes easier—but fans are left waiting for a more convincing display on the pitch.